ThoughtProof — Epistemic Verification Skill

Multi-agent verification protocol for AI decisions. Like a TÜV for AI reasoning.

How It Works

ThoughtProof runs your question through multiple independent AI agents (different model families), then a critic layer identifies blind spots, and a synthesizer produces a consensus with confidence scores.

Pipeline: Normalize → Generate (3+ models) → Critique (adversarial) → Evaluate → Synthesize

Prerequisites

• pot-cli installed: npm install -g pot-cli
• At least one API key (Anthropic, OpenAI, xAI, or Moonshot)
• More keys = more model diversity = better verification

Quick Start

Verify a claim or decision

tp verify "Should we use microservices or monolith for our MVP?"

Chain context from previous verifications

tp verify --context last "What about scaling considerations?"

Deep analysis with rotated roles

tp deep "Is this investment thesis sound?"

Configuration

pot-cli reads config from ~/.potrc.json:

{
  "generators": [
    { "provider": "xai",       "model": "grok-4-1-fast" },
    { "provider": "moonshot",  "model": "kimi-k2.5" },
    { "provider": "anthropic", "model": "claude-sonnet-4-6" }
  ],
  "critic":      { "provider": "anthropic", "model": "claude-opus-4-6" },
  "synthesizer": { "provider": "anthropic", "model": "claude-opus-4-6" }
}

Show current config: tp config

Model Diversity Requirement

ThoughtProof enforces ≥3 different model families for generators. This is core to the protocol — no single provider can verify itself.

Output

Each verification produces an Epistemic Block:

• Proposals from each generator (independent reasoning)
• Critique identifying blind spots, contradictions, and risks
• Synthesis with consensus score, confidence level, and dissent
• MDI (Model Diversity Index) — measures independence of reasoning

Blocks are stored locally as JSON and can be reviewed with tp list / tp show <n>.

Commands

Command	Description
tp verify <question>	Run full verification pipeline
tp verify --context last	Chain from previous block
tp deep <question>	Deep verify: multiple runs, rotated roles, meta-synthesis
tp list	Show block history
tp show <n>	Show a specific block
tp config	Show current configuration

Tiers

Tier	Agents	Time	Best For
Light	3	~30s	Quick sanity checks
Standard	5-7	~3min	Business decisions
Deep	7-12	~5min	High-stakes, regulatory

When to Use ThoughtProof

• High-stakes decisions — investment, legal, medical, compliance
• Audit trail needed — regulatory, governance, due diligence
• Blind spot detection — when you suspect a single model is biased
• Cross-domain questions — where no single model is expert

When NOT to Use

• Simple factual lookups (Google it)
• Creative writing (subjective, no "correct" answer)
• Time-sensitive queries under 30 seconds
• Questions with trivially verifiable answers

Architecture Note

ThoughtProof is BYOK (Bring Your Own Key). Your API keys, your data, your models. Nothing routes through ThoughtProof servers. The skill is MIT-licensed; the consensus protocol is BSL-licensed.

References

• references/block-format.md — Epistemic Block JSON schema
• references/consensus-protocol.md — How consensus is calculated